IF Competition 2000 Games

I didn't write reviews. Lots of other people are going to be writing reviews, and besides, I was an author, so presumably my objectivity is a little off. But as I was playing the games, I started to notice certain trends in what I enjoy in a game and what I don't enjoy. So I'm taking a different approach: I'm writing a series of essays on IF design, using Comp 2000 games as examples.

Everything I say here is intended as constructive criticism. Think of it as a really big, comp-wide version of SPAG Specifics.

Warning: these are spoilery. Games mentioned are listed, though, so if you want to avoid being spoiled, take note.

NPC Implementation: One of my favorite topics. Got ID?, Metamorphoses, Big Mama, Being Andrew Plotkin, 1-2-3, Kaged, Masquerade.

Prose Style: writing something we can stand to read. Comp00ter Game, Threading the Labyrinth, The Big Mama, Masque of the Last Faeries, The Trip.

Description: what goes into a good piece of descriptive prose. Masque of the Last Faeries, Kaged, Shade, End Means Escape.

PC Voice: conveying attitude. Punk Points, Dinner with Andre, Masquerade, Kaged, Enlisted, Rameses.

Pacing: managing the plot. Planet of the Infinite Minds, The Clock, Shade, Amnos.

In-jokes and the IF Community: the author's relationship to the audience. Being Andrew Plotkin, Shade.

More about Shade: my totally spoilerful take on what was going on in this game. Still not a review; more of an analysis. Also, partway through it starts to spoil Adam Cadre's novel Ready, Okay!. So be prepared.

Back to Main Page
All text and images on these pages copyright Emily Short, 2000.
Contact me at emshort@mindspring.com with any questions or comments.